Chameleons Are Cool: The Camouflage Myth, Corrected

Chameleons Are Cool: The Camouflage Myth, Corrected

Chameleons Are Cool: The Camouflage Myth, Corrected details

Chameleons do not change color to match their surroundings.

That sentence is the whole reason this note exists. Nearly every adult believes the opposite. It is in cartoons, it is in the way people use the word chameleon about a person who fits in anywhere, and it is wrong in a specific and interesting way. Martin Jenkins is a conservation biologist, and his book is short and aimed squarely at a five-year-old. I have not been able to confirm from outside the book what its factual line says about why the color changes, so I am not going to tell you it gets this right. What I can give you is the real answer, and a ten-second way to find out what your copy says.

It is a Read and Wonder title, so a story line and a factual line run together on the page, and the whole thing takes about eight minutes out loud.

Here is the check. Find the page or two about color. If the text says the color changes to match whatever the chameleon is sitting on, that is the myth, and you have just been handed the best kind of teaching moment. If it says the color has to do with temperature, mood or signaling other chameleons, the book has it right. Either way you will know in about ten seconds, and either way this note works.

The science it actually teaches

If not camouflage, then what.

The science of chameleons, from the Chameleons Are Cool note: it is not camouflage, dark to warm, pale to cool, color is a conversation, two eyes, two directions, the tongue is a catapult, feet built like tongs.
What a child can come away knowing.

Two things mainly, and neither one is hiding. The first is temperature. A chameleon is a lizard, it cannot make its own heat, and its color changes how much of the sun's warmth its skin takes in. A cold chameleon in the morning goes dark, because dark absorbs. The same animal, too hot in the afternoon, goes pale, because pale reflects. That is not decoration. It is a thermostat with no moving parts, worn on the outside.

The second is talking. Color on a chameleon is a signal aimed at other chameleons. A male warning off another male. A male courting. A female saying she is not interested, or that she is already carrying eggs. A loser in a fight going drab and dark to say it is over. The display is loud on purpose, and being seen is the entire point of it. That is the exact opposite of camouflage, which is what makes the myth so irritating once you can see it.

Chameleons do hide, and they are good at it, but they hide with shape and stillness. The body is flattened like a leaf. The everyday coloring already sits in the greens and browns of the plant it lives in. The walk is a slow rock forward and back that reads to a watching bird as a leaf in a light wind. That is the camouflage. The color change is a separate system that happens to use the same skin.

While you are correcting one thing, correct two. Most people pushed on how the color change works will say pigment, like ink spreading through the skin. Pigment is part of it. But research in the last decade or so found that the bright colors come from a layer of cells holding a lattice of tiny crystals, and the animal changes the spacing of that lattice. Change the spacing and you change which wavelengths of light bounce back at you. It is closer to what makes a soap bubble shimmer than to what makes paint blue. Your child will not get that out of this book, because it is newer than this book is. They will get it from you, standing on the page where the colors change. A nine-year-old keeps that one for good.

Two more facts worth having while you are on the page. The eyes work independently, each one riding its own turret inside a fused eyelid with nothing but a pinhole for the pupil, so the animal watches two directions at once and gives up almost nothing. Then, when something worth eating turns up, both eyes swing forward and lock on the same point, because you cannot judge distance with one eye and the tongue only gets one attempt.

Then the tongue. It is longer than the animal's own body and it does not work the way a muscle pulling works. Elastic tissue behind it is loaded up like a drawn bow and released, which is how it leaves faster than any muscle could pull it, and the tip arrives wet and gripping rather than sticky the way tape is sticky. If your child takes one mechanical fact away from all this, take that one, because it explains the speed instead of just being amazed at it.

The feet are worth ten more seconds. The toes are fused into two opposed bundles, so each foot closes on a branch like a pair of tongs, and the tail wraps around as a fifth limb.

On depth: this is a picture book and the factual line runs a sentence at a time. Deep it is not, so do not buy it for the anatomy. What matters is which idea a five-year-old walks away with about the color, and that is why the check comes first. A wrong idea installed early is worth more effort to prevent than it sounds, because the wrong idea is what everybody else is going to hand them.

The child it lands with

Do you have the child who corrects people? The one who has already informed a grandparent that a tomato is a fruit, and enjoyed it enormously? This is ammunition, and this note gives you the accurate version, which is the part that matters.

Past that, the reptile child, the one standing at the lizard tank in every shop and every museum until somebody physically moves them. And, being honest about it, the adult holding the book, who is the most likely person in the room to learn something.

One place to stop and talk

You are probably the one about to be corrected here, and that is the best use of this book.

Before you open it, say what you think you know. Chameleons change color to blend in. Say it out loud, in front of your child, as your answer. Then read the color page and let the book, or this note, contradict you. If the book agrees with you, that is an even better lesson: a printed book can be wrong, and you can go and check.

That is a small piece of theater and it does two jobs at once. Your child gets the fact, which they were going to get anyway. Your child also gets to watch a grown-up be plainly wrong about something ordinary, notice it, and change their mind on the spot without any fuss or any face-saving. The second thing is most of what science actually is, and it is close to impossible to teach by describing it.

Then leave a question on the table that you cannot answer either. If color is for talking, who is it being said to, and what happens to a chameleon that lives on its own.

What to know going in

Nothing in this book is frightening, and nothing dies on the page except insects, which are caught and eaten in the ordinary way an animal book shows it. The caution here is a different shape.

First, this is an older book, and two things follow from that. Check what it says about why the color changes, which is the whole point of this note. And however it says the skin does it, that part has moved on considerably. If your child comes away with pigment as the mechanism and stops there, they are carrying an older answer to a question that got a better one.

Second, and this is the real one. A child who reads this is going to want a chameleon. Chameleons are among the hardest reptiles to keep alive in a house. They need particular light, particular humidity and a supply of live insects, they hide illness until it is well advanced, and the pet trade has taken real numbers out of wild populations. Have that conversation before you open the book, not three weeks into the campaign.

Where to get it

It is $8.99 in paperback at Chameleons Are Cool. Buy it for the child who cannot leave the lizard tank alone, and run the check on the color page the day it arrives. If it has the science right, nine dollars is a cheap way to keep a false fact from being installed in a five-year-old, one that would otherwise take twenty years and an argument to get back out. If it repeats the myth, you have a printed error and a note that tells you exactly what is wrong with it, which is a better lesson than most worksheets. Either way, the reptile books already on your shelf are worth checking against the same question. The rest of the Stealth Science shelf is one click away.

If your child liked this one

Books we have written about that sit close to this one, by reading level and by subject.

Cover of Big Blue Whale by Nicola Davies

Big Blue Whale: Why Nothing on Land Gets This Big

Big Blue Whale by Nicola Davies
Grade K to 3

See the book

Cover of Surprising Sharks: Read and Wonder by Nicola Davies

Surprising Sharks: What the Word Shark Actually Covers

Surprising Sharks: Read and Wonder by Nicola Davies
Grade K to 3

See the book

Cover of What If You Had Animal Scales!? or Other Animal Coats? by Sandra Markle

Animal Scales: Fur, Feathers and the Same Five Jobs

What If You Had Animal Scales!? or Other Animal Coats? by Sandra Markle
Grade K to 3

See the book

Cover of What If You Had Animal Teeth? by Sandra Markle

Animal Teeth: Which What If You Had Book to Buy First

What If You Had Animal Teeth? by Sandra Markle
Grade K to 3

See the book

Browse every book we have written about by age, by kind of book and by subject: Find the right book for your child. Or see the whole Stealth Science shelf.